Ian Somerhalder as Damon, Nina Dobrev as Elena, Paul Wesley as Stefan. Photo by Andrew Eccles / The CW ©2009

We don’t want to spoil the most amazing season finale ever before you’ve even seen it, so if you haven’t had a chance to watch “Founder’s Day” yet–first of all, what are you waiting for? And second of all, there are bound to be SPOILERS in the comments, so wait until you’ve watched to read on.

Honestly, we went into “Founder’s Day” thinking that Bonnie’s witchy lie would be the undoing of everything and everyone that we hold dear in Mystic Falls. But you can’t blame the most shocking season finale surprises on Bonnie! We’re still reeling from the way things ended for everyone from Jeremy, to Damon, to Elena–aren’t you? Tell us what shocked you the most!